The Citizen and the Alien
Dilemmas of Contemporary Membership
Chapter One
DIVIDED CITIZENSHIPS
POLITICAL AND LEGAL thought today are suffused with talk of citizenship.
Whether the focus is equal citizenship or democratic citizenship or social
citizenship or multicultural citizenship, whether the preoccupation is
with civil society citizenship or workplace citizenship or corporate
citizenship or postnational citizenship, some version of citizenship is
now vital to the intellectual projects of scholars across the disciplines.
Citizenship talk pervades our popular political discourse as well.
Citizenship, however, is a more confounding concept than most who employ
the word usually recognize. Citizenship is commonly portrayed as the most
desired of conditions, as the highest fulfillment of democratic and
egalitarian aspiration. But this, I believe, reflects a habit of
citizenship romanticism that tends to obscure the deeper challenges that
the concept poses. These challenges derive from citizenship's basic
ethical ambiguity. The idea of citizenship is com ... read full excerpt from The Citizen and the Alien: Dilemmas of Contemporary Membership ebook