Scott got into a fair amount of trouble as a teenager, but now he's grown and runs a respectable auto body shop. Unfortunately, the sheriff of his town has it out for him, no matter how much he's cleaned up his act. When he's accused of a crime he didn't commit, no one is more surprised than he is when straitlaced Michaela Miller provides him with an alibi. An alibi that's a complete lie. Determined to find out why his sexy next-door neighbor helped him out, he puts himself in danger of losing something he'd never considered. His heart.